Who should censor children’s books?
Thursday, February 22nd, 2007Over on Elizabeth Kennedy’s About.Com website for children’s books, there is a survey about who should censor our children’s books. When completing it, I chose “other”, because I felt that both parents, educators and librarians should be involved. In fact, I don’t even think that much of what is screamed is censorship at all, but is respect for parents’ rights to determine what is appropriate to read. Here is the response I left on the website:
I think that everyone should be involved in what children should be reading. As a parent, I frequently see thinly veiled, deliberate attempts by educators to make available, even force, our children to read books that many parents find offensive or that denigrate parents moral values and undermine their parental influence.
In compulsory activities, like public k-12 education, parents have a right to enter into the discussion of what is appropriate in the classroom and in the library, as well. This isn’t censorship and it isn’t banning, because no one is saying that the book can’t be sold or published. It is acting on behalf of the parents who are ultimately responsible for raising their children as best they can.
In excluding certain books from public schools, these books’ availability has been limited to a certain extent, but only limited. Other parents can obtain these books and provide them to their children, if they choose. No one is stopping them. If someone were, then that would be censorship.
Public schools frequently court fights with parents when they deny parents a role in determining what is appropriate for their children. They court fights when they pooh-pooh parents’ concerns, or belittle them, or ignore them. They court fights when they include offensive books in the curriculum and force students to either hide their books from their parents to prevent a row, or to challenge their instructor by choosing an alternative book for class. These fights undermine parents’ trust and support for public education. These fights undermine public support for public education.
In light of this, school administrators, teachers, and librarians should be sensitive to the broad range of moral sensibilities of the parents of their students and respect those moral sensibilities rather than turn blue in the face and begin screaming.